Zebu Forno Red Bank NJ Prowns Home Improvements Red Bank NJ Taste Red Bank NJ
Two River Theater Company Red Bank NJ

COUNCIL TO CLUBS: ‘SHUT IT’

Noisecurfew

Once a month at Teak, after the diners have finished their Asian-fusion sushi, a merengue band sets up in the front room and the place explodes with sounds from south of the border.

In fine weather, the large windows on three sides of the room are thrown open, turning the place into a throbbing lanai on Monmouth Street as salsa dancers spill out into the parking lot.

Well, it may be the dead of summer, but it’s time to button up, borough officials say.

The borough council is dialing up a campaign against nighttime noise with a proposal that would force clubs and restaurants to shut their doors and windows after 11p when they’re playing music, whether live or recorded.

“As more and more places go to big open windows — which is lovely — the noise is becoming more intolerable for the neighbors of those establishments,” says Councilwoman Grace Cangemi.

A recent surge in residential life in the downtown district is driving the move, Cangemi says. “Especially as we encourage more mixed-use development, we want to make sure everyone knows what the rules are,” she says.

Mayor Pasquale Menna is more critical of the bars and restaurants. He says that there seems to be an arms race of sorts in which “establishments are dueling with each other for decibel levels.”

The council introduced an ordinance Monday night that would require all non-religious establishments to close their portals when playing music after 11.

It doesn’t say the music must halt; only that the doors and windows have to be closed.

Cangemi, who spent many years working as stage manager for rock and jazz concerts — “joy of joys, I’ve worked for every horrible heavy metal act in the world,” she says — now runs the Rock ‘ Roll Music Fund, a charitable organization that puts on shows to rase money for needy causes.

“After a lifetime in the music business, I’m the last person to say we want to stop the music,” she says. “We just want you to close the doors.”

Under ordinances already on the books, there are decibel limits on allowable noise, and clubs must close at 2a. Fines for violations range up to $2,000.

Menna says there should be no first warnings to violators of the proposed law. “I’m of the firm belief that after you give them notice (of a new ordinance), you shouldn’t give a grace period,” he says.

The one club manager redbankgreen has been able to talk to about the ’shut it’ rule so far was unfazed by it.

“We usually do it most of the time anyway,” says Kira McElwain, of Red, on Broad Street.

Cangemi said that while the proposed ordinance has its roots in complaints from residents, it came about after she, Menna and Councilman John Curley tried to have a conversation one night recently in the parking lot of borough hall. They couldn’t hear each other over the music coming from Buona Sera on the opposite side of Monmouth Street, she said.

A public hearing on the proposed ordinance is scheduled for the next council meeting, at 5:30p July 9.

Email this story

Zoe An American Bistro Little Silver NJ
  • wow- what a wste of time. a couple of establishments in red bank play music a little too loud and its disturbing the neighbors. how about the latin music that pulses out of the overcrowded rental houses in red bank? these rentals are acutally in resedential neighborhoods. Its happening all over red bank. 25 people living in a two family home. while we are on the subject of noise problems- how about the red bank taxis that pick up the people who live in these overcrowded houses and beep their horns over and over until someone finally gets in to them. This happens at all hours of the night. Taxis will just keep honking until someone pops out of these homes. I also think that the town should post the names of the owners of the homes who are in violation and the results of the fines they recieve.

    Posted by: resident on June 27, 2007 at 8:50 am | Permalink
  • Speaking about noise…..can we get a Harley Davidson loudness ordinance? Perhaps a "Rice Burner" ordinance? These thundering and screaming motorcycles have become so bothersome that I am considering moving away. Sleeping with the windows of your home open in this town during the spring, summer and fall is a real challenge. Strange that when a politician is inconvienced by not being able to chat because of music and folly laws need to be changed or enforced. Well Pat Menna would you like to have a sleep over at my house one Fri or Sat night? Want to hear real noise? At least the noise generated by music, fun and clubs represents the borough's vitality. The thundering, wall shaking, throttle wristing club goers who leave these venues between 2 and 3am is what really bothers me. Get real Mr. Mayor, you have bigger fish to fry.

    Posted by: Alex on June 27, 2007 at 9:01 am | Permalink
  • Resident and Alex are you aware of the Neighborhood Watch program which is a great venue for you to address your problems.They meet the second Wednesday of the month at River Street Commons.We do get results.

    Posted by: Carl on June 27, 2007 at 11:43 am | Permalink
  • The council introduced an ordinance Monday night that would require all non-religious establishments to close their portals when playing music after 11.

    Hmmm, why do they think religious noise is not as loud?

    I wonder if these churches and their functions in Red Bank donate any money to the campaigns of these pundits.

    Noise is noise and as a non-religious person it aggravates me that relgious noise is protected. To me noise is noise so you either have a ban for everyone or a ban for no one. People wonder why Americans are always divided, certain groups get favored over others.

    Off my soap box I step.

    Posted by: Keith on June 27, 2007 at 11:54 am | Permalink
  • Thank you city council!

    Just last night at 3:00 am until almost 4am somewhere in the vicinity of Monmouth and Broad live jazz music echoed through the downtown. How is that possible when the bar/restaurant are to close at 2am??

    You try sleeping on a hot summer night with that nonsense. On a week night? Saturday I can understand, but not at the beginning of the week.

    As for the Harley's thundering through town and the taxi's honking senslessly at all hours, that is another whole set of issues the council need to address.

    Regulating loud music beyond the confines of the establishment is just the start….Yes please close those windows and doors!

    Posted by: Cheryl on June 27, 2007 at 1:03 pm | Permalink
  • I am not an attorney, but I suspect there are legal reasons to exclude religious establishments. In either case, I really don't understand why this would bother someone so much. I am not aware of any religious establishments creating noise problems at these hours in the evening, unless that Easter midnight mass is too much of a disturbance.

    I find it dubious that any of the religious establishments in town are giving money to the mayor and council in order to pass this ordinance. I doubt they care. Such allegations should not be made unless there is evidence of such a claim.

    God bless

    Posted by: Rob Boyle on June 27, 2007 at 2:34 pm | Permalink
  • "Its happening all over red bank. 25 people living in a two family home. while we are on the subject of noise problems- how about the red bank taxis that pick up the people who live in these overcrowded houses and beep their horns over and over until someone finally gets in to them. This happens at all hours of the night. Taxis will just keep honking until someone pops out of these homes."

    Up north, we call that the "Hoboken doorbell."

    Think of it as just more diversity to "celebrate" as RB becomes more "vibrant."

    The NY Times editorial staff thinks this is a good thing.

    Posted by: BLB on June 27, 2007 at 11:26 pm | Permalink
  • I have been able to control taxi beeping on my street a little. For 5 years I dealed with it but I had enough. So what I do now is I walk over to the taxi driver ask them where they live and when they tell me I say thanks because I will beep my horn in front of your house tomorrow.So it has cut it in half.

    Posted by: Joe on June 28, 2007 at 5:11 am | Permalink
  • It is somewhat unfortunate establishments require an ordinance to force courteous behavior when operating their business!

    Live entertainment is a huge attraction for Red Bank. We moved to RB to live in a vibrant city. This is what we asked for. But not at the expense of sleep!

    We're neighbors AND we're patrons.

    (Good move, borough council.)

    (..living within a block of Teak, The "Dub", and so-on.)

    Posted by: Ken Ameika on June 28, 2007 at 9:03 am | Permalink
  • Noise pollution is becoming quite an increasing problem in RB. I feel for those folks who live near the loud music venues.

    Music is not my noise problem but lawn service is. It is not pleasant to be woke up at 6:45A, or 7:00A, or 7:30A to the beutiful sounds of a gas lawnmover, a gas edger and the best of all, two gas blowers. Not everyone has to rise at 5:30A….some of us work later hours and don't need to be up until 8:00A. There should be enforcement of the ordianance that says 8:00A for loud noise and it should be amended to say no noise before 9:00A on weekends.

    Posted by: Robert on June 28, 2007 at 1:28 pm | Permalink
  • All of the above comments have documented merit and I thank you for yor opinion. The state master plan was thrust upon us during the previous administration providing a mixed use of retail and residential. Fortunately or unfortunately many of our residential streets back up to restaurants, bars and night-clubs and many rent apartments nearby. It is the councils intention to keep the music playing in Red Bank and keep the rythem of our town intact. A little compromise goes a long way to ensure the well being of all. Many of our establishments already compromise as they contiue providing the entertainment so pertinent to the vitality of Red Bank. THERE IS NO RESTRICTION OF ENTERTAINMENT just a thoughtful request to close the windows turn up the air conditioning and enjoy the music. See you there!! John P. Curley Councilman

    Posted by: John P. Curley on June 28, 2007 at 11:08 pm | Permalink
  • Someone should buy the Councilman a Dictionary!

    Posted by: sallyfromsyracuse on June 29, 2007 at 9:27 am | Permalink
  • another knit picker. PROBABLY JUST TYPOS SALLY THRY HAPPRN ONVE IM A WHILR

    Posted by: gary on June 29, 2007 at 4:30 pm | Permalink
  • Sorry for any typos Sally! The sentence structure however was perfect, I Think? Please review. What are your feelings regarding the ordinance? Please let us know. I will try not to type after 11PM. John P. Curley Councilman

    Posted by: John P. Curley on June 30, 2007 at 9:52 am | Permalink
  • Count your blessings and forget the typos! Members of the city council come to this forum and listen to us squabble.

    If Mr. Curley, Mr. Menna, and the rest of the gang come onto RBG; they're getting your feedback.

    Contrast it to the "good old days," where the only feedback an elected official gets would be on election day or at some protest..

    Keep it going, man!

    Posted by: Ken Ameika on June 30, 2007 at 10:03 am | Permalink
  • Hooray for Alex! I thought I was the only person angry with the increasing number of loud motorcycles driven through Red Bank.

    I have never understood how someone could get away with deliberately altering a machine to make it extremely loud, then driving it around where a lot of people live.

    Many of these motorcycles are so loud they cause me physical pain. My elderly neighbors are awakened three or four times a night, and it is impossible for the young mothers on our street to get their babies to sleep through the night. These jerks are making life miserable for everyone, and somehow it hasn't occurred to the administration that it might be a real problem.

    By the way- who benefits from parking enforcement? who benefits from noise enforcement? Which is enforced with its own officers? Which isn't enforced at all?

    P.S. Take a good read of this NY Times article and the accompanying photo. You will need it to respond to the police chief, town attorney, and city manager when they look you square in the face and tell you noise enforcement is "technically infeasible":

    http://www.nytimes.com/2007/06/30/nyregion/30noise.html?fta=y

    Posted by: B. J. Firani on July 2, 2007 at 11:17 am | Permalink

    • Click teeth to read "comments on comments" file. Click GIF file to enlarge.
  • recent comments:

    • 09.03 - 21st annual Filmmakers Symposium It's the Fall Session of the special sneak preview screening event series organized by Chuck Rose, and available by subscription only at the AMC Loews Monmouth Mall multiplex for 12 weeks beginning September 21. Some bonafide special guest stars are promised in person, along with an advance look at dozens of new and forthcoming major studio releases (along with the best of the big festivals). Visit www.PrivateScreenings.org for a complete list of films and info on subscribing, or call 1.800.531.9416. Discounted registrations available through September 3.
    • 09.03 - End of Summer Party on Sandy Hook On September 10, the Sandy Hook Foundation presents its annual fond farewell to the season of summer concerts and activities on the Hook, with some of the area's finest restaurants and caterers doing their thing they do so well, plus live music and auction items offered by a selection of local merchants. Proceeds support restoration, maintenance and education projects of the National Park Service. Party entrance is at the North Beach Pavilion near the Fort Hancock area; RSVP online.
    • 09.03 - First Friday for Seniors The Monmouth County Library's Eastern Branch hosts Maura Attardi in a free presentation for seniors on LIVING ON A FIXED INCOME. Coffee and light refreshments served.
    • 09.03 - 3rd Annual Holiday Express Sunset Clambake On September 19, the non—profit powerhouse of seasonal cheer and positive energy holds their annual fundraiser, with Tim McLoone and the band on hand as both guests of honor AND in—house entertainment, with a splendid buffet and open bar, gift auctions and more. Admission (200 dollars per guest) benefits the ongoing good works of the Holiday Express organization, and attendees are urged to register online or call 732.544.8010 by September 10.
    • 09.03 - Brett & Bill In Concert As part of the Mayor's Chill Out Jazz Series at the Asbury Park Transportation Center, longtime AP residents and internationally renowned singers (they're also the hardworking guys who run the Algonquin Arts Theatre in Mansaquan) BRETT COLBY ad BILL WHITFIELD perform a FREE evening of jazz, pop and Broadway standards — with beverage sales going to benefit the Arts Coalition of Asbury Park (ArtsCAP).
    • 09.03 - Fair Haven Fireman's Fair The Big One! A touchstone of local life and an event whose joyous good times are nearly tempered by the melancholy that signals the onset of another school year. All the standbys are back for this 51st year at the River Road firehouse: the Ferris wheel and firetruck rides; the 'Out Back' snack bar and out—front kiddie rides; the Super 50/50 and the seafood kitchen. In fact, we'd suggest you start lining up right about now!
    • 09.03 - Red Bank Walking Lantern Ghost Tours Jersey Shore Ghost Tours invades Red Bank once again, with guided nocturnal tours of the borough's most historical haunts, every Friday night through Halloween. Tours and ticket sales meet at 8pm in front of The Dublin House; reservations recommended at 732.500.6262.
    • 09.03 - OLD MONEY First Avenue Playhouse presents a comedy about elderly counterfeiters, clueless kinfolk, hapless mobsters and a scheming girl scout. It's served up with coffee and dessert; visit the website for details on available dinner/show packages.
    • 09.04 - Jody Joseph: One Legend, One Diva, One Woman On September 25, the First Lady of Shore barband rock pays tribute to Janis Joplin and Stevie Nicks — with a portion of proceeds donated to the nonprofit Mary's Place by the Sea.
    • 09.04 - SEVERE CLEAR On September 11, the Count Basie Theatre honors the memory of Lincroft's Beth A. Quigley and the other victims of the 9/11 attacks, with a special screening of the documentary SEVERE CLEAR, directed by Colts Neck filmmaker (and Iraq War vet) Michael Scotti. The director joins the Quigley family in person at this event, a benefit for the nonprofit organization ReserveAid. Doors open 7pm for a one hour cash bar; tickets (50 to 100 dollars) available from the Basie box office and additional info at www.reserveaid.org.
    • 09.04 - Buc Backer Bash at RBR On October 30, Red Bank Regional High School presents a Booster Club fundraiser, with music, games and prizes inside the gymnasium and all proceeds dedicated to the RBRHS sports teams. More info and reservations (25 bucs; adults only) at bucbackerbash@aol.com.
    • 09.04 - SkimBash 2010 Competition On September 11 and 12, skimboarding pros and enthusiasts from all over the USA converge on Sea Bright for the annual competition, sponsored by The Mad Hatter and Skim City and hosted this year on the municipal beach behind Borough Hall and awarding trophies in categories ranging from 5—8 year olds to grownup professionals. $$25 event registration (75 for pros) gets entrants an event t—shirt, lunch and other giveaways. There's live music too, and the Sunday finals are open to spectators free of charge!
    • 09.04 - Touch a Truck at RBMC TICKETS ON SALE NOW for September 25. It's a chance for kids to climb aboard a firetruck, sit atop a bulldozer and, yes, touch a truck — and it's presented 'rain or shine' as a fundraiser by Monmouth Day Care Center from 10am to 2pm in the parking lot of Red Bank Middle School. There's also face painting, a 50/50 raffle, food vendors and more; tickets (10 dollars per family; kids must be accompanied by adult) can be purchased in advance by calling 732.741.4313.
    • 09.04 - Paddle the Navesink Day On September 18, Navesink River Rowing presents a 'community wide celebration of the river;' a chance to walk or row the Red Bank riverfront and check out the all that the borough has to offer in recreational activities along the Nav. Included are free kayaking lessons and demos from Jersey Paddler, tennis on the clay courts at Marine Park, sailboat rides and food from Monmouth Boat Club, tours of the North Shrewsbury Ice Boat Club, plus seining, fishpainting, canoeing and a tour of the oysterboat Adam Hyler. All activities are free and it all starts at Maple Cove (foot of Maple Avenue off West Front Street). Call 732.241.9532 or 732.693.3067 for more info.
    • 09.04 - Fair Haven Fireman's Fair The Big One! A touchstone of local life and an event whose joyous good times are nearly tempered by the melancholy that signals the onset of another school year. All the standbys are back for this 51st year at the River Road firehouse: the Ferris wheel and firetruck rides; the 'Out Back' snack bar and out—front kiddie rides; the Super 50/50 and the seafood kitchen. In fact, we'd suggest you start lining up right about now!
    • 09.04 - OLD MONEY First Avenue Playhouse presents a comedy about elderly counterfeiters, clueless kinfolk, hapless mobsters and a scheming girl scout. It's served up with coffee and dessert; visit the website for details on available dinner/show packages.
    • 09.05 - Twin Lights Bike Tour On September 26, the Highlands Business Partnership and Bike New York host the 9th annual biking event through some of the state's best seashore and countryside scenery. Online registration available at www.bikenewyork.org. Registration/check—in at Huddy Park, Highlands, at 7am.
    • 09.05 - Tour de Fair Haven On September 19, the Borough of Fair Haven and the FH Business Association team up with USA Cycling Federation to host the annual biking event (a 3.1 mile closed course along the Navesink) that commences from the Fair Haven Firehouse at 7am — with kids' races and family activities following at 1pm. It's a benefit for the Joan Dancy & PALS (People with ALS) Foundation, and more info can be had at 732.449.2254.
    • 09.05 - Red Bank Farmers Market Fresh, locally grown produce from some of New Jerseys finest farmers, plus equally homegrown crafts, at this Sunday morning staple running May through the middle of November in the Galleria parking lot.
    • 09.05 - Reach Up at United Methodist Church United Methodist Church of Red Bank introduces a 'casual, informal,new kind of worship experience,' one in which 'you don’t have to be Methodist. You don’t even have to be Christian. Just have a desire to explore your own spiritual being.' It's come as you are, with no reservation needed.
    • 09.05 - The Highlands Community Singers The summer season of free concerts at the Atlantic Highlands Municipal Harbor Gazebo concludes with this traditional homegrown offering at 7pm.
    • 09.05 - Open Mic with Rob Dye and Mike Ghegan A tradition around Red Bank for years, the Sunday night event is THE place to find musicians congregating, hanging out, trying new ideas, cutting up on some classics and generally enjoying one of the MUST events for Jersey Shore music fans.
    • 09.06 - Lunch Break 2010 Fall Gala On October 4, the Red Bank based nonprofit presents A NIGHT OF SONGS & TASTES OF OLD ITALY, hosted by Rumson resident and Hollywood actress Siobhan Fallon Hogan and featuring Italian songs by Tony winning actor John Leone. There's also a smorgasbord of samplings from top area restaurants and caterers, silent auctions and more. It happens at Two River Theater; contact info@lunchbreak.org for additional details, or call Toni at 732.747.8577.
    • 09.06 - Philosophy as a Way of Life On September 13, the NJ Branch of the School of Practical Philosophy presents a lecture by Russell Bosworth, based on Pierre Hadot's book about how the study of the great philosophers can lead to life of happiness and greater awareness. It's hosted at King of Kings Lutheran Church in Middletown; visit philosophyworks.org/events for more info.
    • 09.06 - Side by Side: Images by Vicki Culver and Norma Kay Little Silver's Boro Hall is the setting for an exhibit of handcrafted photo collages by Vicki Culver and digital art photography by Norma Kay; on view through September 30 during regular hours.