Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

BUILDER AGAIN REJECTED ON TREE APPEAL

Fair Haven planning board members Larry Quigley, foreground, and Pat Drummond with board attorney James Moody at Wednesday’s hearing. (Click to enlarge)

By JOHN T. WARD

With members voicing unvarnished regret over their own votes, Fair Haven’s planning board refused to hear a developer’s second appeal of an aborted tree-removal permit Wednesday night, setting the stage for expected litigation.

Expressing frustration with both the town’s controversial tree ordinance and having to sort through a tangle of arcane legal principles, board members told homebuilder Bob Susser that there was nothing they could do for him in his quest to remove a 60-foot tree that two arborists, including the town’s, have said is healthy but in danger of “catastrophic failure.”

With only four members eligible to vote, the board unanimously found that the new appeal failed to meet the legal criteria of being “substantially different” from the first one in order for the full board to hear it.

“I’m sad about that,” said Alison Dale, one of the four. “I want us to be helpful here.”

The tree in question, a tulip poplar, is smack in the middle of the footprint of one of three houses that Susser has approval to build, under board OK of a subdivision of the property, on Woodland Drive.

Susser bought the property from Elizabeth Lilleston and her husband for $1.5 million in August. But the matter flared into controversy when it became widely known that Lilleston, who as the town’s code official enforces the tree ordinance, had previously issued Susser a permit to remove the tree from the property.

That prompted Mayor Mike Halfacre to order the tree permit rescinded, on the basis of an apparent conflict of interest, and thrust Susser into a series of reviews that even some local officials questioned whether they had the jurisdiction to hold.

Most recently, in December, the planning board voted 3-2 not to allow Susser to remove the tree.

A full appeal of that decision was blocked Wednesday night, after the four who were present and voted at last month’s hearing concluded that the two appeals were not all that different, and rather, in the words of board chairwoman Joan Jay, just “another bite at the apple.”

But the vote came only after prolonged tussling over the critieria for legal constructs such as res judicata, which says, in essence: the matter has been decided; game over.

Along the way, the tree ordinance was repeatedly teed up as weak on guidance to those who have to uphold it, with new member Bob Marchese, who is also on the borough council and has failed in the past to have it abolished, using the phrase, “despite how much I detest the tree ordinance.”

Before it was over, however, Susser made an impassioned plea, telling the board that if he had lived on the property  and asked to take down the poplar – one of some 60 trees on the site – chances are good he would have been approved because two tree experts agreed it was a danger to the house that was directly below.

And even if the permit were denied, he could have appealed to the town council, and almost certainly come away satisfied, he said.

Paraphrasing  Halfacre, Susser said “the council has never denied a homeowner the right to take down a tree.” The borough always exacts a cost, often in the form of replacement trees, but no one has yet been told no, Susser said.

Now, he said, “we are proposing a better legacy for the property,” relocating a number of trees, and replacing three to be cut down with 14 new ones.

Yet, “I’m being treated unequally,” he said.

Jay was almost apologetic in shooting him down.

“Given the framework of the ordinance, I don’t see that we have a choice, and you will have to seek satisfaction elsewhere,” she told the obviously frustrated builder.

Susser, of Rumson, and his lawyer, Brooks Von Arx, declined comment afterward. Several of the board members, however, said they fully expect the town will to have to defend itself in a lawsuit as a result.

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
Partyline
EASTER EGG MAYHEM AT THE PARK
An errant whistle spurred an unexpectedly early start to the Spring Egg Hunt on Sunday, which had been scheduled to begin at eggsactly 11am ...
PRESEASON DOCKWORK
RED BANK: With winter winding down, marina gets ready for boating season with some dockwork on our beautiful Navesink River.
CORNED BEEF AND DISCO FRIES?
It’s Friday, and smart Lent-observing Leprechauns know the pot of gold at the end of Red Bank’s rainbow is actually the deliciou ...
SURFBOARD DITCHED
It’s a violation of etiquette in surfing to ditch your board.  (it could hit another surfer and hurt them). But someone appears to ha ...
ELSIE, TAKE ME WITH YOU!
Soaked by pouring rain with the temperature hovering in the low 40’s, this sign in the window of Elsie’s Subs on Monmouth Street ...
WALK THIS WAY
PARTYLINE: Before-and-afters of a sidewalk cleanup on West Street.
SOGGY NOTION
RED BANK: Breezeway sculpture captured the mood downtown as heavy rains fell Saturday morning.
HOME DELIVERY
RED BANK: After a subdivision, an instant house rises on a new Catherine Street lot.
COMMUNITY PROFILES
For Black History Month, Red Bank's Community Engagement and Equity Advisory Committee has been running a series of local profiles on Facebo ...
HEARTY FAREWELL FOR HARDY
RED BANK: Council to honor DPU supervisor Rich Hardy, who retired recently after almost 39 years of keeping things running.
HOMEBOUND? READ ON…
RED BANK: Can't get to the public library? It's now offering free delivery and pickups for homebound borough residents.
TAMING A BEAST OF A WEEK
RED BANK: After the second snowfall of the week, a borough family finds the perfect use for it – a Godzilla snow sculpture.
RED BANK: LIBRARY CLOSED, BUT THE HILL’S OPEN
RED BANK: Though the library was closed by a snowstorm, kids got to enjoy the riverfront property's steep slope Tuesday.
LIGHT(HOUSE) MAKEOVER
This year, getting ready for spring means a midwinter makeover for Strollo's Lighthouse in Red Bank.
TODAY: LOCAL PUPPY COMPETES ON ANIMAL PLANET’S “PUPPY BOWL”
Red Bank’s very own rescue puppy, Biscuit, is set to compete in Animal Planet’s Puppy Bowl this Sunday, February 11, at 2 PM. Th ...
WHAT? NO redbankgreen NEWSLETTER?
Apologies to redbankgreen newsletter subscribers: the daily email hasn’t gone out for two days because of technical issues.
RED BANK: TIRED OF SKEETERS?
RED BANK: Tired of mosquito bites every summer? Monmouth County has a free program to help eliminate skeeter breeding grounds.
SEA BRIGHT: POLAR PLUNGE FOR ST. JAMES, OTHERS
Hundreds braved the wind and sea on Sunday at 1PM in support of St. James Elementary School, and other Catholic schools in the area. The eve ...
RED BANK: RBR CLAIMS TITLE
RED BANK: Watch pure joy as the RBR boys basketball team celebrates its first B North championship in 17 years.
RED BANK: FORGET-IT FRIDAY
RED BANK: Train Station can be a lonely place Friday mornings, especially with cold rain in the forecast.