Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

CUT DOWN, BUILDER TRIES NEW TREE PLAN

The health of the tulip poplar at center, above, has been a pivotal issue in the dispute. Below, the developer’s latest tree plan. (Click to enlarge)

By JOHN T. WARD

An ethics issue, arcane rules about tree removal and the opposition of neighbors have turned a three-house subdivision in Fair Haven that once appeared problem-free into a movable battle of wits and passions.

On Wednesday night, Buttonwood Investors returns to the planning board for yet another go-round over its Woodland Drive property.

This time, however, it has a new plan for dealing with trees.

The revised plan, submitted December 27, contains no narrative description of what it entails, only the schematic drawing shown above. Buttonwood principal Bob Susser and the company’s attorney, Brooks Von Arx, declined comment when contacted by redbankgreen.

According to planning board secretary Judy Fuller, the proposal calls for the removal of three trees, rather than the original seven. A comparison of the two plans appears to show that a much-debated tulip poplar, located smack in the middle of the footprint for the proposed northernmost of the houses, would still be removed.

The request marks the latest twist in a flap over trees in a town that has had its share of them.

Last month, the planning board narrowly rejected an appeal by Buttonwood of a tree-removal permit denial.

The board had previously approved the subdivision, which required no variances. That was after redbankgreen reported that the seller of the property, Elizabeth Lilleston, had also approved Buttonwood’s tree-removal plan in her capacity as code enforcement officer.

Lilleston, who with her husband sold the property for $1.5 million in early August, said she had discussed the potential conflict of interest with Clerk Allyson Cinquegrana last spring. But as no alternative review process was spelled out in borough laws, the matter stayed with Lilleston, who hired a tree expert and, on the basis of his report, approved the permit in May, she said.

After an outcry by neighbors, however, borough officials yanked the tree-removal permit and kicked the matter over to Rumson for review in another venue. But Rumson officials declined to get involved.

So the permit issue went to back to Fair Haven, to the desk of Administrator Theresa Casagrande, who rejected the permit after consulting an arborist, Bill Brooks of Red Bank. She concluded the permit would have allowed for the removal of a “significant specimen tree,” a classification that’s protected under borough ordinance.

After that, the matter went up on appeal to the planning board, amid uncertainty about jurisidiction. The ordinance says only that appeals should go to “a board,” planning board chairwoman Joan Jay told redbankgreen recently. “It doesn’t really spell out under which circumstances you go to which board.”

Casagrande “felt it should go to the planning board,” she said.  “But we don’t normally deal with trees.”

At a well-attended meeting in December, Brooks and an arborist for Buttonwood agreed that the tulip poplar, “while not diseased, is structurally unsound” and in danger of catastrophic failure of its giant twin trunks, Jay said.

“I wouldn’t know a tulip poplar if it came up and introduced itself to me,” Jay said. “But when I hear ‘catastrophic failure,’ my thought is that I don’t want it over my house.”

Jay, however, was in the minority on a 3-2 vote by the board to reject the appeal.

But even with the focus on the poplar, Carrie Eustace, who grew up in and again lives in a house directly across Woodland Drive from the site, said in her view, the tree is “a side issue.

“I think the tree is worth preserving,” she said. But the bigger concern, she said, is that “squishing – and I say squishing – three houses onto that lot is not in keeping with the aesthetic of this neighborhood. It’ll no longer be one of the prettiest streets in Fair Haven.”

The hearing is at 7:15 p.m. at borough hall.

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
Partyline
THEY’RE BACK!
Ospreys returned to the skies over Red Bank this week for the first time since they migrated to warmer climes in late fall. With temperature ...
SPRING IS SPRUNG
RED BANK: Spring 2024 arrives on the Greater Red Bank Green with the vernal equinox at 11:06 p.m. Tuesday.
RED BANK’S FINEST – AND NEWEST
Red Bank Police Officer Eliot Ramos was sworn in as the force’s newest patrolman Thursday, and if you’re doing a double take thinkin ...
EASTER EGG MAYHEM AT THE PARK
An errant whistle spurred an unexpectedly early start to the Spring Egg Hunt on Sunday, which had been scheduled to begin at eggsactly 11am ...
PRESEASON DOCKWORK
RED BANK: With winter winding down, marina gets ready for boating season with some dockwork on our beautiful Navesink River.
CORNED BEEF AND DISCO FRIES?
It’s Friday, and smart Lent-observing Leprechauns know the pot of gold at the end of Red Bank’s rainbow is actually the deliciou ...
SURFBOARD DITCHED
It’s a violation of etiquette in surfing to ditch your board.  (it could hit another surfer and hurt them). But someone appears to ha ...
ELSIE, TAKE ME WITH YOU!
Soaked by pouring rain with the temperature hovering in the low 40’s, this sign in the window of Elsie’s Subs on Monmouth Street ...
WALK THIS WAY
PARTYLINE: Before-and-afters of a sidewalk cleanup on West Street.
SOGGY NOTION
RED BANK: Breezeway sculpture captured the mood downtown as heavy rains fell Saturday morning.
HOME DELIVERY
RED BANK: After a subdivision, an instant house rises on a new Catherine Street lot.
COMMUNITY PROFILES
For Black History Month, Red Bank's Community Engagement and Equity Advisory Committee has been running a series of local profiles on Facebo ...
HEARTY FAREWELL FOR HARDY
RED BANK: Council to honor DPU supervisor Rich Hardy, who retired recently after almost 39 years of keeping things running.
HOMEBOUND? READ ON…
RED BANK: Can't get to the public library? It's now offering free delivery and pickups for homebound borough residents.
TAMING A BEAST OF A WEEK
RED BANK: After the second snowfall of the week, a borough family finds the perfect use for it – a Godzilla snow sculpture.
RED BANK: LIBRARY CLOSED, BUT THE HILL’S OPEN
RED BANK: Though the library was closed by a snowstorm, kids got to enjoy the riverfront property's steep slope Tuesday.
LIGHT(HOUSE) MAKEOVER
This year, getting ready for spring means a midwinter makeover for Strollo's Lighthouse in Red Bank.
TODAY: LOCAL PUPPY COMPETES ON ANIMAL PLANET’S “PUPPY BOWL”
Red Bank’s very own rescue puppy, Biscuit, is set to compete in Animal Planet’s Puppy Bowl this Sunday, February 11, at 2 PM. Th ...
WHAT? NO redbankgreen NEWSLETTER?
Apologies to redbankgreen newsletter subscribers: the daily email hasn’t gone out for two days because of technical issues.
RED BANK: TIRED OF SKEETERS?
RED BANK: Tired of mosquito bites every summer? Monmouth County has a free program to help eliminate skeeter breeding grounds.