Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

SHREWSBURY: PANTER CLAIMS WIN v. O’REILLY

By JOHN T. WARD

mike-panter-1-220x220-7053800A Shrewsbury man claimed victory Tuesday in a yearlong legal standoff with former Fox News star Bill O’Reilly.

Former New Jersey Assemblyman Mike Panter, right, said O’Reilly dropped a $5 million defamation suit he’d filed over a Facebook post in which Panter recounted an ex-girlfriend’s allegations of sexual harassment by the combative TV host.

Documents filed in the Eastern District of New York federal court confirm that O’Reilly voluntarily dismissed the case against Panter last week. Panter announced the end of the litigation in a press release, issued Tuesday, in which he referred to O’Reilly as a “disgraced pundit.”

An attorney for O’Reilly did not respond to a redbankgreen request for comment Tuesday evening.

O’Reilly sued Panter in New York supreme court in October, 2017, after Panter used Facebook “to call bullshit on” O’Reilly’s protestations that he had not sexually harassed women.

In a post, Panter recounted the purported experience of an ex, a former Fox employee he did not identify, in her dealings with O’Reilly. Panter claimed to have listened in on a phone conversation in which O’Reilly tried to coerce the woman into providing dirt on another Fox employee who had accused O’Reilly of sexual harassment.

“I heard every word, as we sat in the car with the windows up,” Panter wrote in the post.

O’Reilly had left his job at Fox six months earlier, after “at least” six sexual harassment claims were filed against him, including one that concluded with a $32 million settlement, according to the New York Times.

At the time, O’Reilly said he sued after Panter “posted a bunch of lies about me on Facebook. As usual, some in the press picked up the deceit and spread it around. There is no way to stop this defamation which has dramatically harmed me and my children. So, now, we will use the courts. I will tolerate no more.”

The suit was later moved to federal court on motions by Panter’s attorney, Lisa Bloom. Bloom had previously represented three women who claimed sexual harassment by O’Reilly, “forcing his termination” by Fox, Panter said in the release.

Panter told redbankgreen that after months of silence from O’Reilly, the suit was voluntarily withdrawn on election day, just a week before “the first real date where [O’Reilly] was going to have to answer arguments and account for his own actions.”

The one-year statute of limitations for defamation cases has now lapsed, so O’Reilly cannot re-file, Panter said

Panter said his aim with the Facebook post, and his determination to defend himself against the suit, was all about standing up for women in the #metoo era.

“I knew I was telling the truth and I knew I had a real solid case from a legal perspective,” said Panter, a non-practicing attorney. “I also knew that somebody with resources like him could drag even a frivolous case out for years.”

Panter served two terms as a Democrat in the Assembly between 2004 and 2008 and now owns a property-inspection business and a financial firm, he said.

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
redbankgreen Classics
Partyline
WINTERIZING WALK
With rowing season now over, Navesink River Rowing member Trish Russoniello and her husband, John Ward, carried her 25-foot rowing shell to ...
COUNT GETS MURAL TREATMENT
A new mural honoring Count Basie facing the Borough Hall parking lot on Monmouth Street. (photo by Partyline contributor Boris Kofman)   ...
TRUMP FAN VICTORY STROLL
A Donald Trump supporter went for a stroll down Broad Street Wednesday morning in a celebration of his win over Vice President Kamala Harris ...
ON ELECTION DAY, REAL FOG TOO
Commuters wait for their train to emerge from the fog in Red Bank on Election Day 2024.
SUNDAY AT LUCIDA
Artist talk at Galerie Lucida with owner and curator Michael Mazzeo and the photographer and co-curator Gerald Slota. Sunday afternoon, Nove ...
REMODEL HALLOWEEN
  Despite undertaking an amazing renovation, the Red Bank family that lives at this home at South Street and Pinkney would not miss out ...
Spooky Celebrations on South Street
Happy Halloween – South Street Style. –Original before GPT– Happy Halloween-South Street Style.
MARIGOLDS FOR DAY OF THE DEAD
Marigolds were the most popular item at Floreria La Orquidea at 192 Shrewsbury Avenue over the past few days as folks bought up the flowers ...
TRICK OR TREAT DJ
A DJ rocks Deforrest Avenue from the front porch of Edgar and Carly Deronde as trick or treaters flock to the street on Halloween night. (ph ...
HALLOWEEN HAIRCUT
Rigo's barber shop on Shrewsbury Avenue always goes all out. Luis Lego gets a Halloween haircut.
T-REX ON RIVER STREET
Looks like a T-Rex is amuck on River Street (photo by Partyline contributor Chris Havens)  
Mysterious Creatures Parade Around Red Bank Charter School
Lots of strange creatures, like this green dragon, emerged from the Red Bank Charter School this morning and paraded around town! (photo by ...
HALLOWEEN SUNRISE
Halloween sunrise over the Navesink River.
SALON CELEBRATES TEN YEARS
Red Bank's L Studio salon throws a bash for its tenth anniversary.
ICE BOAT JACK O’ LANTERN
The ice boat emblazoned Red Bank borough seal in jack o’lantern form, at the jack o’ lantern drop at Riverside Gardens Park Thur ...
NEW MURAL TAKES SHAPE
The leaves aren’t the only thing getting a splash of color this Fall. On Shrewsbury Avenue, a vibrant mural is in process, adorning bo ...
Spectacular Autumn Sunset at Warwick Gardens
Autumn Sunset in Red Bank – Warwick Gardens on Pinckney Avenue. (photo by Partyline contributor Adam Kaplan)
EYES ON YOU
Huge eyeballs in a front yard in Red Bank. (photo by Partyline contributor Jeff Frieri)
VIDEO: RED BANK HALLOWEEN PARADE
 
MURALIST BRIGHTENS TACO SHOP
  Jim Fitzmaurice paints a new mural on the side of International Mexican Grocery  (which is not a grocery but an eatery very popular ...