Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

RED BANK: COURT NIXES TAX ACTION

riverview-medical-center-060217-3-500x375-8857335The borough’s attempt to revoke Riverview’s tax exemption for two years amounted to a “fishing expedition” in search of justification, the court ruled.  (Photo by John T. Ward. Click to enlarge.)

By JOHN T. WARD

hot-topic_03-220x138-220x138-7378486Red Bank can’t retroactively revoke the tax-exemption for Riverview Medical Center, New Jersey’s tax court ruled last week.

In attempting to do so, the borough was improperly hoping that a “fishing expedition” in the form of legal action would turn up evidence that the hospital, owned by Hackensack Meridian Health, was being used as a for-profit facility, the court ruled.But the ruling is “very limited,” addressing only Red Bank’s effort to impose new assessments on Riverview for tax years 2014 and 2015, Mayor Pasquale Menna told redbankgreen Thursday. It does preclude the borough from moving ahead with pending tax cases covering the years 2016 and 2017, he said.

The case involved Red Bank’s effort to effectively revoke exemptions previously granted by the borough assessor, Mitch Elias. It followed an unrelated case in which Morristown successfully argued in court that Morristown Medical Center did not meet the requirements for not-for-profit status for at least two years.

AHS Corporation, which owned the hospital, later agreed to a settlement under which it would pay property taxes for a portion of its holdings, according to a report by Morristown Green.

In the Red Bank case, Judge Mala Sundar issued a 20-page decision packed with arcane issues of tax law on July 25. The court found that Red Bank had wrongly relied on the Morristown case, and granted Meridian’s request for a summary judgment dismissing the borough’s action.

In 2016, the borough council initiated action at the Monmouth County Board of Taxation in an effort to impose “omitted assessments” on the hospital property at 1 Riverview Plaza for tax years 2014 and 2015, the court’s summary of the case said.

The action was not aimed at nullifying the entirety of the hospital’s tax exemption, Menna has previously said. Rather, it was about determining how much of Riverview’s holdings deserve exemption from property taxes.

But “there was no proffer of any evidence, including any action by the assessor, nor any asserted change in use or ownership by RMC, to support the allegations contained in the petitions,” the court ruled.

Moreover, when the hospital pushed back, Red Bank “claimed to have no documents or communications between the Borough, the assessor’s office, the County Board or the Division of Taxation, or any documents maintained by the assessor relative to the grant or denial of the exemption, ” the ruling says.

Instead, the borough argued that the legal process of discovery, in which it would request documents from Riverview, would yield material to support its claims.

But the court found that Red Bank’s “own responses to RMC’s interrogatories were that it has absolutely no documents evidencing any change in use.

“There was no inspection, observation, or finding by the assessor that the Subject [property] was not being used for non-profit purposes during the 2014 or 2015 tax years,” the decision said.

“As RMC correctly argues, the Borough is using the discovery process as a fishing expedition and as an attempt to find support for denial of an exemption,” the court found.

Menna said the borough council, which is slated to meet on August 15 under an altered summer schedule, is expected to discuss the ruling in executive session and decide whether to appeal.

Meantime, he said, the town’s tax cases against Riverview for 2016 and ’17 are still active, Menna said. The cases have gone to discovery and there have been settlement discussions, but one has not been reached, he said.

A hospital spokeswoman did not immediately reply to a redbankgreen request for comment.

The riverfront hospital’s assessed value is a $67.8 million, according to public records. Last year, the hospital halted its voluntary Payment in Lieu of Taxes, or PILOT, which reduced borough receipts by $277,000. Councilman Michael Ballard said the cessation was one reason borough property taxes rose nearly 5 percent this year.

Information on how much the effort cost the town was also not immediately available.

On its website, the New Jersey Hospital Association said the Morristown decision prompted nearly 40 lawsuits “pitting municipalities against their local not-for-profit hospitals. Legislation, rather than litigation, can help identify a reasonable balance that would allow hospitals to contribute to the municipal services they use without jeopardizing hospitals’ ability to care for their communities.”

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
redbankgreen Classics
Partyline
JUNETEENTH CELEBRATION
Performers at Red Bank’s Juneteenth community celebration Sunday at Johnny Jazz Park. (photo by Brian Donohue)      
BUTTERFLIES LOVE THE WEED
Save the monarch, plant butterfly weed. (photo and text by Partyline contributor Roseann DalPra)  
LANTERNFLY PARTY
An invasive ailanthus tree sprouting in front of the US Post Office on Broad Street is covered with invasive spotted lantern fly nymphs Wedn ...
STREETCORNER SERENADE
An Irish doodle named Cheddar listens to native New Jerseyan, singer/songwriter and former Houston resident Tom Foti, (identified in the hea ...
Red Bank 5K Fun!!!
Red Bank Classic – June 14th, 2025 (photo by Partyline contributor Adam Kaplan)  
RAINBOW OVER RED BANK
Saturday, before and after the storm that rolled through town. (photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus)    
Mini Ballers Bring the Heat at Fusion Basketball School
As the temperatures heat up, so does the competition in the mini baller clinic at Fusion School of Basketball. These little tykes are intens ...
DOZENS OF PLEIN AIR ARTISTS “PAINT RED BANK”
Plein air artists take over town for first ever "Paint Red Bank" event. (click to read)
RED BANK: SIGN ON ICONIC DANNY’S STEAK HOUSE COMES DOWN
The sign hanging from the shuttered Danny's Steak House comes down ten months after a manager reported Danny's Steakhouse would be back "bet ...
FOR YANKEES FANS, GOOD TRASH PICKIN’
A collection of framed photographs of Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Joe DiMaggio and other New York Yankees greats was placed curbside along with a ...
RED BANK: NEW HANDICAPPED PARKING, WEST SIDE MEETING PLANNED
New handicapped parking sign West Side advocate had pressed for is installed, with meeting planned to discuss other concerns. (click to read ...
SUNSET AT SUMMER’S START
Crazy sunset clouds shot from Monmouth Boat Club on the Friday evening at the start of Memorial Day weekend, the unofficial start of summer. ...
SIDEWALK GOES FROM WORST TO FIRST
P (photo by Brian Donohue) What had been, in our estimation – and apparently in the eyes of the several people who have emailed and te ...
RED BANK: PEERING FROM ON HIGH, ACROSS THE DECADES
Roofers on the Azalea Red Bank top off the project in the shadow of a sculpture depicting another generation of construction workers who toi ...
BRICK FACELIFT CONTINUES ON MONMOUTH STREET
A million-dollar brick sidwalk makeover of Monmouth Street in Red Bank continues.
JAY AND SILENT EAGLE
A very loud blue jay squawks at an indiferent bald eagle in a treetop alongside the Swimming River in Red Bank this week. (Partyline photo b ...
PIZZA LOVING SQUIRREL SPOTTED IN RED BANK
Pizza squirrel spotted in Red Bank. (click to read)
GET YOUR MA SOMETHIN’ NICE AT THE RED BANK FARMERS MARKET
It’s a beautiful and sunny Mother’s Day for the first instance of the farmer’s market, held every Sunday, beginning in May ...
SIGN? WHAT SIGN?
Folks in Red Bank Wednesday exercising their riparian rights to access tidal waters first encoded into Roman law in 500 AD and later adopted ...
FANTASTIC MR. FOX
Partyline contributor captures photo of backyard fox.