Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

STATE LANDS ON SEA BRIGHT & CLUBS

The state of New Jersey has apparently had it with Sea Bright beach club owners—and the borough, too—over the question of just who owns the beach.

Beach2_1

Using a pair of court rulings as leverage, acting Attorney General Anne Milgram today sued Sea Bright and nine private beach clubs for failing to provide unrestricted public access to shorefront that state claims was “almost entirely built through a publicly funded shore protection project in 1995.”

The multifaceted suit also accuses Sea Bright of breaching an agreement to convert the former site of the Peninsula House hotel to a public beach. Instead, the state claims, the borough has left the parcel in disrepair and even tried to barter it away for landlocked property for the site of a new municipal building.

And Sea Bright hasn’t paid a dime of the more than $556,000 it owes the state for its share of a 2003 beach replenishment, the state claims. It demands payment.

In addition to the borough, the defendants in the suit, filed in the Chancery Division of Monmouth County Superior Court, are Surf Rider Beach Club, Donovan’s Reef Beach Club, Chapel Beach Club, Water’s Edge Beach Club, Sea Bright Beach Club, Driftwood Beach Club, Ship Ahoy Beach Club, Trade Winds Beach Club (now Kara Homes), and The Sands Beach Club of Sea Bright.

A call to Sea Bright Mayor Jo-Ann Kalaka-Adams was not immediately returned.

The lawsuit is an effort by the state to nullify agreements signed with the beach clubs in 1993, prior to the start of a massive sand-pumping program that widened beaches from Sandy Hook to Barnegat Inlet. Those agreements required the borough and the clubs to allow the public a 15-foot wide “transit corridor” of dry sand at the water’s edge for strolling and fishing only.

The state now contends, however, that additional beachfront created by the sand-pumping programs doesn’t belong to the private clubs. It argues instead that up to 250 feet of new beachfront created by a renourishment program in 1995—and secured by a 2003 replenishment—is covered by the doctrine of public trust, which grants public access to riparian lands.

The state’s case is bolstered by two court rulings, one in U.S. District Court and another at the New Jersey Supreme Court, the lawsuit contends.

Yet the defendants have continued to “insist that they may have exclusive use of this publicly funded beach, need not provide public access to the ocean… and may receive additional future sand replenishment at public expense” over the life the original 40-year agreements, the suit contends.

“This request is utterly appropriate in light of the long succession of court decisions striking down exclusive practices on municipal and private beaches and the extensive, long-term investment of public money that has been made in these beach areas,’’ Milgram said in a prepared statement.

The 35-page lawsuit notes that Sandy Hook, just to the north of Sea Bright, is often filled to capacity with beachgoers by noon on a summer’s day. The clubs, meanwhile, “maintain private exclusive access to and use of the entire dry sand beach area” that was paid for with public funds, the suit contends.

Sea Bright, the suit says, maintains inadequate parking and bathroom facilities for public usage. The borough also owes the state more than $556,000 for its portion of the 2003 replenishment, the lawsuit claims.

E-mail this story

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
redbankgreen Classics
Partyline
RBMS HOOPS CHAMPS HONORED
The Red Bank Middle School girls basketball team is honored for their championship season. (click for more)
NAVESINK SUNSET
Sunset sunburst over Riverside Gardens Park (photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus)
RIVERSIDE SUNSET
Sunday’s sunset shot from Riverside Gardens Park. (Photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus) —
MARINE PARK SUNSET
Stunning sunset from Red Bank's Marine Park.
GULLS AND GRAY OVER MOLLY PITCHER INN
On a cold rainy spring day, bulls soared high above the Navesink River and the golden cupola of Red Bank's Molly Pitcher Inn.
Red Bank Commuters Enjoy Stunning Sunrise Over Navesink River
Thursday morning sunrise over the Navesink River, a commuter view from NJ Transit Train 3320. (photo by Partyline contributor Karly Swaim) & ...
SUNRISE OVER MONMOUTH STREET
Sunrise over Monmouth Street Thursday morning (photo by Partline contributor Thomas Doremus)
FINAL STRAW FOR MARINE PARK REMAKE
Workers place a straw covering over the now-dirt (soon to be grass) stretch of Marine Park that had been an asphalt parking lot for generati ...
DEER IN RED BANK
Dear Friends –Original before GPT– Deer Friends
GHOSTBUSTERS ON MONMOUTH STREET
Ghostbusters vehicle spotted on Monmouth Street. (photo by Partyline contributor Roseann DalPra)
BOAT CLUB AND BATTLESHIP GREY
Monmouth Boat Club under the past weekend’s clouds. (Photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus)    
CURBSIDE BLOOMS
Broad Street beautified. (photo and text by Partyline contributor Boris Kofman)  
NEW MURAL TAKES SHAPE AT CANNABIS SHOP
Red Bank artist Michael White, donning a hat fitting for the day of the New York Mets’ home opener, works on a new mural at Canopy Cro ...
CHERRY BLOSSOMS ABOUND IN RED BANK
Cherry blossoms are everywhere! (photo and text by Partyline contributor Boris Kofman)  
DOWNTOWN RED BANK ON A FRIDAY AFTERNOON
Downtown on a Friday afternoon. (partyline Photo by Thomas Doremus)  
LIGHTS ON THE NAVESINK
Thursday’s post-sunset clouds over the Navesink (Partyline photo by Thomas Doremus)  
A SPRING IN THE STEP
A man walks carrying a bouquet of flowers beneath the blooming trees in Red Bank. (Partyline photo by John T. Ward)  
ROWING INTO SPRING
Beyond the magnolia trees in full bloom at the Red Bank Library, the Navesink River Rowing Advanced Youth Program heads out for their weekda ...
RED BANK GREEN VISITS AUSTRALIA
Publisher Kenny Katzgrau is representing Red Bank and Red Bank Green at the Local and Independent News Association Summit in Melbourne, Aust ...
MAGNOLIA IN BLOOM
My neighbors’ magnificent magnolia. (photo and text by Partyline contributor Raseann Dal Pra)