Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

YMCA EXPANSION PLAN FAILS

cymca-plansSketches  for the proposed Community YMCA expansion, which the zoning board rejected Thursday night. (Click to enlarge. Photo by Dustin Racioppi)

By DUSTIN RACIOPPI

Though it got more votes in favor than against, a proposal to nearly double the size of the Community YMCA facility on Maple Avenue in Red Bank isn’t going to happen anytime soon.

After months of back-and-forth over design plans and the Y’s acceding to some concerns of the borough zoning board — to the degree that every board member praised its efforts  — the plan failed to win the votes it needed to move forward.

The board voted 4-3 in favor of the plan, but because a use variance was at issue, the YMCA needed a supermajority of five or more votes, said board attorney Marc Leckstein.

Board chairwoman Lauren Nicosia had recused herself over a conflict of interest and Chris Ferrigine was absent.

cymca-hearing

A crowd sat through three hours of discussion and testimony that focused on tree preservation, solar panels and parking. (Click to enlarge)

Hearings on the proposal went on  for months, with the Y’s architects starting over nearly from scratch after board members complained the initial building concept looked too “futuristic,” with large glass windows. It didn’t fit in with Maple Avenue’s existing homes and businesses, they said.

The redesign also moved an entire section of the building to accommodate the request of the Shade Tree Commission to save a few trees and created more parking, including handicapped and “courtesy” spaces.

The YMCA had commissioned traffic and parking studies, and their plans brought forward Thursday conformed to all the recommendations of those experts, said lawyer Marty McGann, who represents the YMCA. Every potetntial condition of approval voiced by board members was greeted with the same answer by McGann: “We will do that. We are not adverse to that.”

The plan appeared to have solid support from an audience that sat through more than three hours of testimony and comments.

Samuel Rennard, three of whose four daughters learned to swim at the Y, got rousing applause when he said to the board, “I don’t care if you knock down every single tree. I don’t care if you take away all the parking spaces,” he said. “It doesn’t matter. We need to take an ounce of common sense and think about this. It helps the community.”

Still, there were those who said the expansion was bad for Red Bank, and more specifically, bad for Maple Avenue.

Joe Buzzanco, a dentist whose office is near the Y, said he’s a member and supporter, but opposed the expansion, mostly for traffic reasons.

“Maple Avenue is a catastrophe,” he said. “It’s the main corridor into Red Bank. This is surely going to make it significantly worse.”

In the end, though, it still came down to what the building looked like relative to its neighbors.

Vice Chairman Tom Williams and first alternate Rosemary Minear  voted against the plan. Williams said the building design was a “stumbling block” for him. A borough ordinance saying that a business or home must essentially blend in, or not interrupt, the existing area, haunted him, he said.

“This is something I kept referring to during the application and for me, it was never addressed,” he said. “I came here tonight with an open mind and now comes time to make the decision. While we’re all going to have to live with it, and I am still stuck on this, I’m not against an expansion, but it’s an inappropriate expansion.”

After the decision, McGann was the closest thing to a loss for words as a lawyer can be. He pondered, walked around a bit, and as reporters circled him awaiting some comment, said, “I don’t know how to characterize it yet. I’m disappointed. I thought the applicant addressed every concern that the board had.”

Williams said the proposal can come back in two ways. The YMCA can appeal the decision, citing capricious action from the board, to state Superior Court in Freehold, which could force the board to re-hear the matter. Or the YMCA can bring in a new plan, completely different plan.

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
Partyline
YAPPY TOGETHER
RED BANK: Look for this cutie pie, named Sacramento, at Yappy Hour on Broadwalk Saturday. He's looking for a new home.
YELLOW RAINCOAT DAY
On a rainy May morning, the only golden sight on Broad Street this morning were the matching raincoats of Eileen and her dog Benny.
STOP. JUST STOP.
RED BANK: For those who don't get the meaning of a stop sign, crossing guard Diane Johnson amplifies the message with some colorful outfits. ...
RECORDS SKIP INTO TOWN
RED BANK: Devotees of vinyl records expected to drop needle at Broad and Mechanic Saturday. Here's why.
Feline fortunes on Monmouth Street
Christopher Russell and feline pal Princess take in some fresh air on a warm May night Thursday in the doorway of Gina’s Psychic Bouti ...
GOING UP?
RED BANK: Public Library will be closed Friday for the start of elevator construction. (Click for more.)
TREEBIRTH
RED BANK: Replacement of nine trees gets underway on South Street, where a wholesale removal angered residents last September. (Click for mo ...
RIVERSIDE FLOW
New Jersey Flow Arts brings together jugglers, poi spinners, hoopers and more weekly in Riverside Gardens Park.
Honeybee swarm carted away
Beekeeper Tanya Ptak of Ptak’s Apiary inspects a swarm of honeybees that chose a flower pot in the courtyard of Red Bank Primary Schoo ...
BELOVED POISONED DOG PHOTO SURFACES
   
THREE ON TOUR
RED BANK: Three borough sites will participate in a weekend of self-guided tours of 52 historic locations in Monmouth County May 4 & 5.
VOLUNTEERS GET INTO THE WEEDS
Toting plastic trash bags, 51 volunteers conducted a walking litter cleanup on Red Bank's West Side Saturday.
“IT’S A PARTY AT WAWA!”
You wish you could vibe like Brian, who lives on the other side of Hubbard’s Bridge. He caught redbankgreen’s attention in Red B ...
POPE OKS ORATORY
RED BANK: St. Anthony of Padua obtains papal approval to establish Oratory of St. Philip Neri, a community of priests and brothers devoted t ...
RED BANK: NEW MURAL BRIGHTENS CORNER
RED BANK: Lunch Break founder Norma Todd is depicted in a mural painted this week on the front of the newly renovated social service agency.
TULIPS TOGETHER
Spring tulips taking in the sunset outside the Molly Pitcher Inn in Red Bank Monday evening.
RIVER RANGERS RETURN
River Rangers, a summer canoeing program offered by the Navesink Maritime Heritage Association, returns this summer for up to 20 participa ...
DOUBLE DYLAN IN RED BANK
Trucks for a production company filming what one worker said was a Bob Dylan biography have lined Monmouth Street the past two days with cre ...
AFTER THE RAIN
A pear tree branch brought down by a brief overnight storm left a lovely tableau on the sidewalk in front of Red Bank's Riverside Gardens Pa ...
CONE OF UNCERTAINTY
Asked by a redbankgreen reporter why these cones were on top of cars, the owner of the car in the foreground responded: “That’s ...