Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

FAIR HAVEN: MARINA LOSES LATEST ROUND

jim-cerruti-112719-1-500x332-8338423Fair Haven Yacht Works owner Jim Cerruti in his boatyard last week. (Photo by John T. Ward. Click to enlarge.)

By JOHN T. WARD

hot-topic_03-220x138-220x138-7378486A Fair Haven marina lost the latest round Thursday night in a years-long and increasingly bitter battle with the borough government over property issues.

At a compliance hearing held in Rumson, Judge Thomas J. Smith III found that Fair Haven Yacht Works had not complied with an earlier ruling that it file a zoning application with the town, and upheld a $1,500 fine.

fair-haven-cerruti-120519-2-500x353-6418774Molly and Jim Cerruti speaking with their attorney, Tony Sposaro, following Thursday’s court hearing in Rumson. (Photos by John T. Ward. Click to enlarge.)

At issue was one of seven zoning violations alleged in July, 2018 by the borough’s code enforcement officer, Nick Poruchynsky, against the marina, located on the Navesink River at the northern end of DeNormandie Avenue.

Some of the purported violations related to a site plan approved by the borough zoning board in 1966, when the marina rebuilt following a devastating fire the previous December. Issues included parking, drainage and boat racks.

Marina owners Jim and Molly Cerruti, who live in the borough, bought the business in 1998.

In July, after two nights of testimony that drew large numbers of marina supporters, Smith dismissed six of the counts as “de mininis,” or minor, and said they appeared to arise from changes made over decades in the normal course of business.

But Smith also found the marina guilty of failing to provide a drainage swale to direct runoff from the property away from DeNormandie Avenue, as directed in 1966. He imposed a $1,500 fine, which he stayed, provided that the Cerrutis apply to the borough to correct the issue within 30 days.

They filed a zoning application for the swale in August, marina attorney Tony Sposaro told the court Thursday. But after a review by an outside engineering firm, at a cost to the marina of $2,392, the borough deemed the application incomplete. It also claimed that in order to make it complete, the marina would have to correct the other six issues that had been the subject of the dismissed citations, he said.

In a letter filed with the court, Sposaro called the borough’s actions “nothing short of outrageous.”  He said the Cerrutis, believing they had fulfilled Smith’s order, withdrew their zoning application.

The Cerrutis claim the enforcement actions constitute harassment, and arise directly from a separate lawsuit filed by the borough in Superior Court against the marina. That dispute, which began in 2015, concerns riparian rights associated with the newly christened Williams, Albert and Robards Park and is pending in Superior Court in Freehold.

The zoning  action “is nothing more than an attempt to exert pressure on us,” for an unknown objective, Jim Cerruti told redbankgreen last week. “It is straight-up harassment.”

Borough prosecutor Anthony Vecchio requested Thursday night’s hearing to ask Smith for an interpretation of his July ruling, and if it obviated the borough’s ability to require compliance with land use law. Seated in the courtroom were about two dozen Cerruti supporters, many of them from the volunteer fire department, where Jim Cerruti serves as president and ex-chief.

Vecchio said the 1966 site plan “was never followed,” and that the marina had over the past 50 years expanded its business “completely outside of the law,” by adding docking slips, eliminating parking spaces and making other changes.

“All the town wanted from the get-go was compliance,” he told the court.

The yacht works’ withdrawal of the zoning application was the equivalent of “never having submitted it at all,” Vecchio said, and the yacht works is  “flaunting the borough’s ability to oversee compliance” with zoning law.

Sposaro argued that Smith’s July dismissal of the six counts should preclude the borough from raising those issues again.

“Bringing us back into court is nothing short of outrageous,” Sposaro said. “It constitutes malicious prosecution.”

But Smith said his prior decision did not, and could not have, barred the borough from its legal right to conduct a “comprehensive review” of land use matters.

“I was not trying in any way to limit the jurisdiction of the zoning board,” he said. “The municipal court is not the place to engage in” interpretations of land use law.

He rejected Sposaro’s request that the fine be waived on the basis that his clients had proceeded in good faith, and gave the Cerrutis 20 days to appeal his ruling.

“Our frustration with the process, the harassment, and the actions of the Mayor and Council is at an all time high,” Jim Cerruti told supporters by email Friday. “What do they want and to what depth will they reach to get it? We are reviewing our legal options.”

No borough officials other than Vecchio appeared to be present at the hearing.

Smith, the municipal judge in Highlands, was sitting in for Fair Haven’s judge, Peter Lucas, who was conflicted out by virtue of being appointed by the borough council. Fair Haven utilizes Rumson’s courtroom as its own.

(redbankgreen plans to take a closer look at the dispute between the borough and the marina in coming days.)

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
redbankgreen Classics
Partyline
SIDEWALK GOES FROM WORST TO FIRST
P (photo by Brian Donohue) What had been, in our estimation – and apparently in the eyes of the several people who have emailed and te ...
RED BANK: PEERING FROM ON HIGH, ACROSS THE DECADES
Roofers on the Azalea Red Bank top off the project in the shadow of a sculpture depicting another generation of construction workers who toi ...
BRICK FACELIFT CONTINUES ON MONMOUTH STREET
A million-dollar brick sidwalk makeover of Monmouth Street in Red Bank continues.
JAY AND SILENT EAGLE
A very loud blue jay squawks at an indiferent bald eagle in a treetop alongside the Swimming River in Red Bank this week. (Partyline photo b ...
PIZZA LOVING SQUIRREL SPOTTED IN RED BANK
Pizza squirrel spotted in Red Bank. (click to read)
GET YOUR MA SOMETHIN’ NICE AT THE RED BANK FARMERS MARKET
It’s a beautiful and sunny Mother’s Day for the first instance of the farmer’s market, held every Sunday, beginning in May ...
SIGN? WHAT SIGN?
Folks in Red Bank Wednesday exercising their riparian rights to access tidal waters first encoded into Roman law in 500 AD and later adopted ...
FANTASTIC MR. FOX
Partyline contributor captures photo of backyard fox.
STRIPER RUN AT MARINE PARK
An angler pulls in a striped bass from the Marine Park bulkhead Tuesday evening. (photo by Partyline contributor Boris Kofman)  
COLD AS CANADA? CHECK.
A pair of goose sculptures propped atop an air conditioning unit on River Street in Red Bank.
SUNRISE OVER A GLASSY NAVESINK
Sunrise over the Navesink River, seen from NJ Transit Train 3320. (photo by Partyline contributor Karly Swaim)  
A BLAST FROM THE PAST
NJ Transit "heritage" locomotive makes an appearance at the Red Bank station.
RBFD SNUFFS OUT SMALL APARTMENT FIRE
A small fire that started in a light fixture at the Colony House apartments in Red Bank was quickly put out by members of the Red Band Volun ...
HEAVENLY RED BANK
Rays burst from behind clouds at the sun begins to set over the Navesink River. (photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus)
IN THE FLOW STATE AT RIVESIDE GARDENS
Flow artists in Riverside Gardens Park Friday night. ( photo by Partyline Contributor Karly Swaim)
MAILBOXES HEAD TO HISTORY’S SCRAP HEAP
Sign of the digital age: mailboxes hauled away from Red Bank post office to storage.
HOVERING CHOPPER
What’s going on here? Last Sunday. Hovering around for quite a while. (Photo and text by Partyline contributor Rosaleen Perry)   ...
RBMS HOOPS CHAMPS HONORED
The Red Bank Middle School girls basketball team is honored for their championship season. (click for more)
NAVESINK SUNSET
Sunset sunburst over Riverside Gardens Park (photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus)
RIVERSIDE SUNSET
Sunday’s sunset shot from Riverside Gardens Park. (Photo by Partyline contributor Thomas Doremus) —