Skip to content

A town square for an unsquare town

redbankgreen

Standing for the vitality of Red Bank, its community, and the fun we have together.

RED BANK: SIMS CONVICTION OVERTURNED

[See UPDATE below]

By JOHN T. WARD

hot-topic_03-220x138-2130637Anthony Sims, who was found guilty in the 2014 shooting of a man seated in a car parked in Red Bank, may get a new trial following an appellate court decision issued Monday.

Sims, 32 years old, was wrongly convicted in part based on statements he gave to detectives without having been told why he was under arrest, the three-judge panel found.

Additionally, because the victim of the Willow Street shooting did not testify at trial, but his statements to police were used, Sims was denied his constitutional right to confront his accuser, the court found.

anthony-sims-2019-185x220-4127625Sims, a former Red Bank resident, is seen at right in a New Jersey Department of Corrections photo from 2019. He remains behind bars, and was represented in the appeal by public defender Joseph Krakora.

In August, 2017, Sims was convicted of shooting Perry Veney of Long Branch as he sat behind the wheel of a car parked in his grandmother’s driveway at 13 Willow Street in April, 2014.

Prosecutors said Veney was struck by 12 bullets; after several surgeries, he was released from a hospital three weeks later.

Sims previously did time for shooting two brothers in the borough 2007, and was out of prison for just two months before he was charged in the Veney attack.

Veney refused to testify at Sims’s trial, but Superior Court Judge Thomas F. Scully allowed police to read from a statement Veney had given to detectives while he was in the hospital.

The jury in the case was not informed that Veney was then in jail and awaiting trial for killing Sims’ brother, Rasheem Palmer, in Eatontown.

Sims was found guilty of attempted murder and other charges. His lawyer asked for a new trial, claiming Veney’s “out-of-court identification testimony violated defendant’s right to confront witnesses,” according to the appellate opinion, which agreed.

“Without being correctly informed of the crime for which he was arrested, a defendant cannot knowingly and intelligently waive his right against self-incrimination,” the panel found.

The appellate judges also found violations of Sims’ Miranda rights during the investigation.

“Not only did the interrogating officers not tell defendant the charges for which he was arrested,” the ruling said, “but they admitted to intentionally misleading defendant by advising him he was arrested for assault—a much lesser offense than attempted murder.”

“Because defendant did not know that he was under arrest for attempted murder when he waived his rights, the [Miranda] waiver was not made knowingly and intelligently,” it continued.

After the conviction, Scully sentenced Sims to 50 years in state prison, imposing an extended term as a result of his prior record. The appellate panel did not opine on the claim in Sims’ appeal that the sentence was excessive.

Asked to comment, prosecutor’s spokesman Charles Webster issued the following statement Tuesday:

We are reviewing the court’s decision at this time. However, we believe there are factual inaccuracies underlying the court’s decision.  We welcome the opportunity to clarify the record in our forthcoming appeal.

The outcome of the murder case against Veney was not immediately available. [UPDATE: Webster said “the trial is on hold until the courts reopen.” The Monmouth County Correctional Facility website shows Veney has been held there since December, 2016.]

Here’s the full opinion, written by Judge Garry S. Rothstadt.

If you value the news coverage provided by redbankgreen, please become a paying member. Click here for details about our new, free newsletter and membership information.

Remember: Nothing makes a Red Bank friend happier than to hear "I saw you on Red Bank Green!"
Partyline
SUNDAY AT LUCIDA
Artist talk at Galerie Lucida with owner and curator Michael Mazzeo and the photographer and co-curator Gerald Slota. Sunday afternoon, Nove ...
REMODEL HALLOWEEN
  Despite undertaking an amazing renovation, the Red Bank family that lives at this home at South Street and Pinkney would not miss out ...
Spooky Celebrations on South Street
Happy Halloween – South Street Style. –Original before GPT– Happy Halloween-South Street Style.
MARIGOLDS FOR DAY OF THE DEAD
Marigolds were the most popular item at Floreria La Orquidea at 192 Shrewsbury Avenue over the past few days as folks bought up the flowers ...
TRICK OR TREAT DJ
A DJ rocks Deforrest Avenue from the front porch of Edgar and Carly Deronde as trick or treaters flock to the street on Halloween night. (ph ...
HALLOWEEN HAIRCUT
Rigo's barber shop on Shrewsbury Avenue always goes all out. Luis Lego gets a Halloween haircut.
T-REX ON RIVER STREET
Looks like a T-Rex is amuck on River Street (photo by Partyline contributor Chris Havens)  
Mysterious Creatures Parade Around Red Bank Charter School
Lots of strange creatures, like this green dragon, emerged from the Red Bank Charter School this morning and paraded around town! (photo by ...
HALLOWEEN SUNRISE
Halloween sunrise over the Navesink River.
SALON CELEBRATES TEN YEARS
Red Bank's L Studio salon throws a bash for its tenth anniversary.
ICE BOAT JACK O’ LANTERN
The ice boat emblazoned Red Bank borough seal in jack o’lantern form, at the jack o’ lantern drop at Riverside Gardens Park Thur ...
NEW MURAL TAKES SHAPE
The leaves aren’t the only thing getting a splash of color this Fall. On Shrewsbury Avenue, a vibrant mural is in process, adorning bo ...
Spectacular Autumn Sunset at Warwick Gardens
Autumn Sunset in Red Bank – Warwick Gardens on Pinckney Avenue. (photo by Partyline contributor Adam Kaplan)
EYES ON YOU
Huge eyeballs in a front yard in Red Bank. (photo by Partyline contributor Jeff Frieri)
VIDEO: RED BANK HALLOWEEN PARADE
 
MURALIST BRIGHTENS TACO SHOP
  Jim Fitzmaurice paints a new mural on the side of International Mexican Grocery  (which is not a grocery but an eatery very popular ...
BIG MOON AND BIG WIN FOR RBC
Football and a Full Moon: Taken around 7:30 PM on Friday, October 18 at Count Basie Field in Red Bank. The Red Bank Catholic football team d ...
HUNTER’S MOON LIGHTS UP THE NAVESINK
The full Hunter’s Moon over the Navesink River Thursday night. (photo by Partyline Contributor Terri Franco)  
COMET OVER RED BANK
Comet Tsuchinshan–ATLAS photographed over the Swimming River from the waterfront public access pathway at the foot of Bank Street Wednesda ...
LIGHT ON THE NAVESINK BANKS
Golden hues usher in the daylight on the Navesink River Tuesday morning, as seen from NJ Transit train 3224. (Photo by Partyline contributor ...